The ultimate range finding binocular test/review

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • The ultimate range finding binocular test/review

    Copied from 6mmBR.com... this is too good not to share.

    http://bulletin.accurateshooter.com/2013/12/ultimate-range-finding-binocular-test-by-precisionrifleblog-com/

  • #2
    Ultimate Range-Finding Binocular Test by PrecisionRifleBlog.com
    PrecisionRifleBlog.com recently published results from the most comprehensive field test of rangefinder binoculars ever conducted. It included virtually every product available in a variety of real-world scenarios, to see which had the best performance in the field in terms of both optical clarity and ranging capabilities. The results are based on over 10,000 data points collected from the field over 3 months of testing. Cal Zant, author of PrecisionRifleBlog.com, published a series of posts with exhaustive details about his optical and ranging tests and results, but we’ll hit the highlights here.




    VOICE FILE: Click Button to Hear Cal Zant TALK about Rangefinder Binocular Test
    Six of the models tested were binoculars, and the other two were monoculars. The Leupold monocular was included for reference, because many shooters have a 1,000-yard rangefinder similar to the RX-1000. The Vectronix Terrapin model was included as the control for ranging performance, because it is known to be an extremely accurate rangefinder (spoiler alert: it is). Cal provides a very detailed side-by-side spec comparison for these models in one of his posts.

    Ranging Test Results
    Each model was used to range 500+ times in a variety of scenarios from 25 to over 30,000 yards. The tests showed these models had similar performance at close and mid-range targets, but at 600 yards their performance started to diverge … so that is where most of the testing was focused.

    The chart below summarizes the ranging performance found on the test targets in ideal conditions, which was from a sturdy tripod, at sunset, with 10+ mile visibility. The exact target shape and surroundings varied, but the targets were all approximately 2 MOA wide, highly reflective, and perpendicular to the rangefinder. Specifics on target dimensions, view from the ranging position, and target surroundings are given in the detailed ranging performance results post.



    Vectronix is the leader of the rangefinder world, and that was proved once again in these tests. The new Leica Geovid HD-B wasn’t far behind them, with accurate ranging beyond 1 mile. The Zeiss Victory RF also had surgical precision off a tripod, although it had a reduced range compared to the Vectronix and Leica. The Bushnell Fusion 1 Mile also proved to be able to range targets out to their claimed max range of 1,760 yards.

    PrecisionRifleBlog.com also tested the ranging performance of each model in bright lighting conditions, and offhand as well. The data from those tests also contained a few surprises. To determine how accurate each model really was, Cal Zant carefully analyzed the results from each model when aimed at precisely positioned, “known distance” targets. To see how those tests turned out, or learn more details about specific models, GO TO full results.

    Optical Test Results
    For the optics tests, Cal’s goal was to find an objective, data-driven approach to testing optical performance. What he came up with was placing eye exam charts from 600 to 1,400 yards with different size letters, and then recording what two different people could accurately read with each model. The data for each unit was summed into a single score so they could be ranked relative to how much detail the testers could make out. More specifics are provided regarding how the test was conducted and how scores were calculated in the optical performance results post. Here are the results from Cal’s data-driven approach:



    The Leica Geovid HD-B edged out the other models for the top spot, with its completely new, Perger-Porro prism design. The original Leica Geovid HD, and Zeiss Victory RF also showed great optical clarity.

    The Rest of the Story
    Cal’s full series of posts is very informative. He’s done tons of analysis on the data, and summarizes it in several charts that provide a lot of insight. Cal is also in the process of publishing detailed reviews on each model, including notes he and the other testers compiled for each unit. They used them all — a lot, so they have a unique perspective on what’s good or bad about each. Find out more at the link below:

    CLICK HERE to Read Full Article with More Info

    Comment


    • Dan80
      Dan80 commented
      Editing a comment
      Its a pity they didn't include the Steiner Military 10x50 LRF binos in their line up, Id have liked to see where they stand compared to the rest. Ive just got myself a set and yeah they are a bit on the heavier side and not a real small unit but Im happy with them. Built like a German tank, actually waterproof for a couple meters, very nice optics, very good range and accuracy. Pitty it doesn't have an inclinometer built in, but does have a scan function. And there is no focus knob, dial in the eye pieces to your individual eyes and then they are always sharply in focus at all ranges.

  • #3
    That's the best review i have ever seen on Range finders !

    How is that Vectronix Vector selling for $23,800, dose it shoot mortars

    Big thanx Vman,

    Comment


    • #4
      Ive ranged my Leica HD-B out to around 1500m no worries biggest thing though with these things at long range is to keep them still but any hunting type range its fine. I dont bother trying to sight on an animal i just point at a tree or large rock nearby.

      Comment


      • Guest's Avatar
        Guest commented
        Editing a comment
        Despite what this review says, I have successfully ranged a water tower out to 1720 yards with my Bushnell 1600, confirmed distance. Degree of error was negligable to my suprise. Very difficult to perform as the unit required a stable platform with zero movement.

        Such a shame about the Terrapin going out of production. I really wanted one.

        The Vectronix units are used to range for artillery crews.

    • #5
      Stuck at work so no pics sorry, but here is a good page on them.

      http://www.steiner-binoculars.com/binoculars/army/military-10x50-lrf

      Comment

      Working...
      X